Showing posts with label Arvind Kejriwal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Arvind Kejriwal. Show all posts

Friday, February 5, 2016

Public shaming for external appearance: Kejriwal and his sandals

I read news about Mr. Kejriwal wearing sandals during India's Republic Day function with some dismay. Initially, I ignored this news item thinking it was just an attempt to sensationalize a very trivial issue. I don't think even this event is worthy of any discussion, but during the following days, I noticed more discussions about this incident that too with photos, and now it seems one person sent him a check to buy some decent shoes. It looks like some people are deeply hurt by Mr. Kejriwal wearing sandals instead of shoes during this function. These hurt Indians are claiming that Mr. Kejriwal by doing this terrible act that too in front of the French Prescient embarrassed the entire India. I really wonder what is the logic behind this? This looks like an ideal case of intellectual bankruptcy. But I am still trying to figure out why they think like this? Let me first say that I am personally not a big fan of any dress codes and myself faced this problem so many times in my life when people were not happy with what I wore on some occasions. I always wondered what was their problem as long as I was not coming naked and wearing clean, non-stinky clothes of my choice. I know very well that any leader of Mr. Kejriwal or Mr. Modi's stature is capable enough to take care of any such attacks. They both have an army of devotees who are willing to fight for them and defend their each and every action. I am not writing this to defend any one of them but I personally went through these experiences myself, and this is why I am making an effort to discuss this issue on my blog.

I know that this type of public shaming of people for their external appearance is real and in this age of the internet, it has become more common. First of all, why do I or anyone else have to follow others as far as the choice of dress is concerned? I am not forcing anyone to dress like me, so why people should have any problem with my dress? People have the freedom to express their opinions in whatever way they want. They are free to object, free to criticize but to ridicule anyone like this is not a criticism but a case of public shaming. To ridicule someone's choice of dress, food, or profession is not something we should be doing. There is no doubt that people like Mr. Kejriwal or Mr. Modi are public figures and their every action is open for public scrutiny but to comment about their or for that matter anyone's external appearance is something we should refrain from doing. It seems that few people want to force their choice on some individual who is choosing his own way to dress. It doesn't affect these powerful public personalities but such behavior becomes a real problem for common people who want to express themselves but then face such public wrath. One should take note that these people are not objecting to Mr. Kejriwal not wearing a suit or a tie but they are very particular about him not wearing shoes. They might be okay with a dhoti-kurta or any other Indian dress but not with sandals or chappals as according to them these things display cheapness or poverty and thus embarrass India. 

Why wearing sandals is so embarrassing to these people? Is it because it displays the poverty or cheapness of that person or the poverty of the entire country? Is it because there is some official dress code for these government functions and he made a serious mistake by violating that dress code? Or is it because it doesn't go very well with current fashion or doesn't suit the dress he was wearing (but how this can be a matter of embarrassment for the entire country)? I am sure all these people know that Mr. Kejriwal is not a poor or deprived person by any standards. He and his family earn more than enough money to afford expensive shoes, phones, or cars, and based on some photos shared by these groups it also seems that he owns some of this expensive stuff like an iPhone. Information about his salary and other wealth is available in the public domain so one cannot also claim that he is trying to hide his wealth by living a simple lifestyle. So, it is very clear that he was wearing those sandals out of his own desire and choice, lack of money or display of fake modesty are not possible reasons behind it. I wonder why these people have a problem with that? Do these people also feel embarrassed to see Mahatma Gandhi's dress? He went to England or to all official or nonofficial functions without wearing any shoes or formal dress. Gandhi always traveled in his single-piece dhoti. Was his dress choice in any way embarrassing for India as a country? Is it difficult for these people to understand that Mr. Kejriwal or Mr. Manohar Parrikar or for that matter any individual has complete freedom to choose what dress or footwear they want to wear. It is within everyone's personal rights to decide what they want to wear on any occasion. We don't elect CMs and PMs to display their fashion sense but we elect them to govern properly. What Mr. Modi, Kejriwal, or anyone else wears during any function is their personal choice. Public shaming of anyone for their appearance is not good and I wonder how these people forgot about this simple etiquette. I also wish that instead of sending money to Mr. Kejriwal, which is a cheap publicity stunt and a total waste of that money as he doesn't need it this person should have sent it to some struggling farmer or some underprivileged person who is in real need of it. Public displays of hunger and poverty and news of farmers committing suicide because of lack of money are more embarrassing for India a politician in slippers. What anyone is wearing during any function is not even a topic worthy of any discussion in mainstream media for a country like India. It can be a time-pass topic but definitely not something to report in national media. I hope we understand our priorities and act accordingly.

Thanks for reading and please share your views on this topic.

[Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing]

Friday, December 18, 2015

An open letter to Mr. Arvind Kejriwal

Dear Arvind,
It was really surprising, if not shocking, to see you shouting angry slurs at the BJP and Mr. Modi on national TV and Twitter. I really thought that you learned your lesson from your horrible outburst against Mr. Prashant Bhushan and Mr. Yogendra Yadav, which was revealed immediately after your party's spectacular victory in the Delhi assembly elections. We all can disagree with others or even can have serious differences of opinion on various matters or criticize each other very strongly without being abusive towards each other. I was under the impression that maybe finally after that mistake you learned to control your anger, at least in public. But it seems that lesson is long forgotten and you are back with your "angry young man" avatar that has very little regard for choice of words while expressing his anger. I agree that you have complete freedom to say whatever you want, after all, the right of freedom of expression comes with the right to offend, but I never imagined that you would take it to the extent that it would sound like abuse. Frankly speaking, my love affair with AAP ended long back, immediately after you decided to resign after 45 days of your brief tenure as Delhi CM. I should accept that I was attracted to your political party because of the presence of a wide variety of people from different backgrounds who don't necessarily subscribe to a single ideology. It was an interesting mix and generated some hope in people like me that maybe people with different sets of ideas can also come together and create something unique that can challenge traditional norms of Indian politics. I must also accept that you guys managed to do that, but that phenomenon was very short-lived. I still agree that your party is somewhat different than all other political parties in India, but that difference is very minute and the gap is narrowing day by day. It still is somewhat different, and I hope it remains like that.

Now, coming back to this particular incident, I agree that Mr. Modi or the central NDA government misused power in their hand. I also agree that CBI was in the past and still today is used as a tool to settle political scores or strike political deals, but didn't you already know all this? Didn't you voluntarily sign up for this job and willingly enter the murky arena of Indian politics after knowing all these facts about predatory and dirty tactics used by central governments to intimidate their opposition? Or somehow you believed that these things won't happen with you and your government? Assuming that even if Mr. Modi or the BJP showed their cowardliness and vengeance, why you didn't show your bravery and sensible nature by facing that inquiry or raid like any common citizen of India? Why do you think that your office is so special that CBI needs to get your permission to raid it? DO they do this if they want to raid any common person's home or office? If according to you, Mr. Modi is a coward or a psychopath then who are you? A brave CM who is crying foul just for a single raid conducted on his office? Or is it the case that as a CM of Delhi, you expect to be treated differently than any other citizen of India? I still remember that you and your party as well as most leaders of other political parties saying on multiple occasions that you all are servants of the common people of India. Especially, you and your party claim to be against the VIP culture. But it seems this rhetoric is only true until you guys win the election and get the power, once you are in government then you all become those VIPs, expect some special treatment, and start behaving like a privileged entity who is above the law. I think you know this, but in case you forgot let me remind you that many common people in India go through these ordeals of search, raids, and arrests every day and there is no one to help them. Many of them go through this as a consequence of their criminal acts but believe me, many are put through this for no fault of theirs, but they all go through this, and hope that the system will do justice to them. They believe in the same system of which you are also a part now, even though the system fails them most of the time. They don't ask for any special treatment. What do you have to say now about the VIP culture and everyone should be treated in the same way? I know, that now you or your supporters will argue that then why any other CM's office was not raided or why some other scam was not investigated. I agree that there are often selective investigations and political vendettas in many cases, but I am sure you expected this. People are raising questions about these things and these things should be questioned, but not the way you are doing now. Also, if there are some allegations against one of the officers in your office, then why not investigate him? Why put conditions that first investigate X and Y, and then come to me or my staff? What happened to the claim that we will not tolerate any corruption or shelter any corrupt officer? Was it just a chunavi jumla, a gimmick to win the election, just like your esteemed opponents do in every election? If it was, then at least let people know about it, so they stop thinking that you and your party are any different than others.

If you expected that nothing of this sort would happen to you or that your political opponents wouldn't play any dirty games with you or they would deal with you using kid gloves or that politics would change overnight, then I must say that I am amazed by your naiveness. Similar things have happened in the past and I am sure they will happen in the future also, but it is you who promised to bring the change of culture, but it seems that now you are trying really hard to fit right into that same culture which you opposed as an activist. Your choice of words was not only wrong, but I am sure it was disheartening for many of your supporters to hear these things coming from you. It puts you in the same line of people who called you a traitor, Pakistani agent, bhagoda, naxal, and whatnot. I am sure you must be enjoying their company as you really tried very hard to be part of that group. Those people also used abusive language and displayed a very low level of personal vendetta and what you did is no different. I would not have bothered to write this mail a few months back, but recently I thought your government was back on track as you guys were really doing some good work, initiating discussions about relevant topics like pollution and air quality of Indian cities, but then this happened. It is like going 5 steps forward and 10 steps backward.

I don't want to make my letter too long and too preachy. I am also not here to tell you what to do and what not to do, I am sure you know this better than me. I just raised a few questions and I hope you bother to think about them and introspect a little. Let me end by citing a very relevant example for you, I am sure you know the name of Sachin Tendulkar. This man is considered a great cricketer not just for the number of records he broke or runs he scored but also for his temperament, consistency, sincerity, and on-field behavior. There are equally great players as far as statistics or records are concerned from his era or eras before and after him, many of them are very aggressive not only while playing cricket but also while dealing with other players on the field, and some of them are even known to be extremely abusive during their on-field behavior. Sachin is different from all those because he never engaged in on-field verbal spats, it is not that he was not abused or people never tried to intimidate him or he was not targeted, opponents from all teams tried all sorts of tactics but Sachin answered all that not with his mouth, but with his bat by scoring runs. His performance answered those insults thrown at him, no doubt that he needed to produce very high-quality performance consistently to deal with on-ground sledding, and this is one of the reasons he is considered a great cricketer. I hope this example inspires you to do something different from now onward. Because it is of no use just to claim that you are different, you also need to show that by your behavior.

All the very best and take care.

Thanks for reading and please share your views on this topic.

[Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing]


Friday, May 8, 2015

Public trial of media, is not a solution Mr. Kejriwal

In one of his recent interviews Delhi Chief Minister and AAP leader Mr. Arvind Kejriwal who doesn't seem to be very happy with the negative media coverage his party and some of its top leaders are receiving nowadays advocated about conducting a public trial of media. One can interpret this statement in various ways, his supporters will obviously justify this statement and point out to some channels that are clearly hostile towards this party whereas opponents of AAP will question this statement and even call it a hypocritic stance because it is coming from a party which is largely perceived as a creation of media. There is no doubt that the media gave disproportional coverage to AAP and its leaders, especially to Mr. Kejriwal in the beginning. Maybe this was because of the novelty aspect associated with the approach of AAP towards Indian politics and the issues they raised. At that time, most of the media was perceived as AAP's friend, and other political parties were complaining about unfair attention to AAP. Because of some recent happenings in AAP and even after their emphatic win in the Delhi assembly elections, they are getting a lot of negative press and now many people are saying that it is not much different than all other political parties. This has resulted in a very hostile attitude towards media from many AAP leaders. It is now no secret that after becoming CM of Delhi Mr. Kejriwal doesn't like public scrutiny or any criticism about himself or his party from any quarters of his own party or from media. It seems he doesn't like the taste of his own medicine.

So, what is wrong with advocating a public trial of media (or for that matter public trial of anyone)? We all know that mob mentality or public trials are dangerous as they are not based on facts and evidence but are based on perceptions. These perceptions can be right or wrong and it is easy to manipulate perceptions. That is why we have courts and judiciary so that there can be an unbiased and fair justice system. Even though this system many times fails to live up to its expectations, most of us will agree that we can not depend on public sentiments to deliver judgments in criminal or other cases. If a public trial becomes a norm, then people with a large fan following will never be convicted as there will be always a huge section of the public who will support their idol no matter what they do. Does Mr. Kejriwal want to go back to this stone age justice system? Is he trying to incite people to take the law into their own hands and deliver judgment based on their own opinions and perceptions rather than going to the courts to get justice? I fail to understand what he even means by a public trial of media and how he wants to conduct it? There is no doubt that media has its own issues and problems. There are many questions about transparency, conflict of interest, and accountability that various media houses need to answer, but definitely public trial is not the solution to resolve any of these issues. Let's also be clear that he was not talking about public debate and discussion, these things go on all the time on news channels, the public trial that he is recommending is something altogether different.

It is also clearly evident that politicians are more media friendly when they are in opposition but the time they get in power they start seeing media as a hostile opponent and nuisance. The same questions that they love to ask when in opposition, they try to avoid once they come into power. This was not expected from Mr. Kejriwal and his party as they claimed to be different and also claimed that they were in politics to change the way it functions but it seems that the politics changed them. I hope he was not serious when he talked about the public trial of media, the role of media is very important in any democracy. Questions about the media's accountability and transparency should be raised, the media can not run away from these questions. I hope Mr. Kejriwal will raise some relevant questions rather than being in a hurry to deliver a verdict against the media.

Thanks for reading and please share your views on this topic.

[Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing]

Friday, May 30, 2014

Mr. Kejriwal and his so-called dramas

AAP leader Mr. Aravind Kejriwals' arrest for refusing to pay bail money has been in the news. Among all the news related to Mr. Modi's swearing-in ceremony this was the only news that managed to get attention in electronic media. They ignored the killing of a couple of soldiers or a rail accident but only focused on these things, but that is media, after all, it is a business and they show what people want to read. Kejriwal's arrest because of his refusal to pay bail was called another drama from his side to attract media attention and cheap publicity. This was not the first time his actions were termed as drama, his decision to reject the big bungalow that normally chief ministers occupy was called a drama, and so was his dharna on the road to demand the suspension of a few police officers. Even driving his own vehicle to the office or his dress was considered as a drama or an attempt to attract media attention. Most of his actions which defied the so-called normal behavior patterns of conventional politicians in India were called drama not only by his detractors but also by the media. Why Mr. Kejriwal's actions are labeled as drama? Why anything that deviates from the conventional norm is labeled as drama by people who like to follow the conventional line of thinking? These are very interesting questions and as usual, Mr. Kejriwal has given us another opportunity to discuss another interesting issue here.

Actually, I have some personal connection with this issue which is the main reason I decided to write this post. There was a time in my life when I absolutely hated to wear a suit or any fancy dress (no matter what the occasion). I still don't like to wear them but back then I was totally against some of these things. Any time I opposed any of these ideas, it was called a drama. That too when I was the one who was opposed to dressing up or for lavish celebrations. People who were dressed up like movie stars were called normal and a person who refused to do that because he really didn't like to dress up was accused of doing a drama. The real problem is that many people can't believe that some individuals don't like to follow conventional norms or stereotypes just for the sake of being accepted by society. Many find it difficult to believe that some people can break the conventional norm and behave differently. It is also ironic that when everyone is wearing flashy, expensive, designer, and fancy stuff, a person with simple clothes is called a dramebaaz.

This mainly happens because people think that if a person can afford these things but still refuses to do so, then they must be a dramebaaz. Poor people who can't follow some of these conventional protocols are not accused in this way but if you can afford it and still don't follow the norm then you are dramebaaz. If you can afford then buy a fancy, expensive, branded car; if you don't do it and are still driving your old, used, or rusted car then you are a dramebaaz. If you can afford designer suites and expensive jewelry, then you should wear them but if you go to parties or functions with very simple or regular clothes then you are a dramebaaz. I am not saying that people who wear expensive clothes, like designed stuff or fancy cars are doing something wrong or should feel bad about it, they have the right to buy and wear what they like. It is their right to choose what they want to wear or what they want to do with their money and their life. I really appreciate their sense of fashion and their ability to manage all these things but some people don't have any interest in these things so why not respect their choice also.

Our society needs to accept that some of us believe in a different set of values and want to live our lives by those values. How can it be called a drama? If Mr. Kejriwal wants to live his life by his own beliefs, he wants to stand up for what he believes is right and is willing to face consequences for his actions, why is it called a drama? This also shows a mindset where people expect everyone to fit in the same mold and behave as per society's norms. We must learn that certain people travel a different path and their choice also matters like everyone else's.

Thanks for reading and please share your views on this topic.

[Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing]

Saturday, February 15, 2014

How Arvind dared to do this?

Delhi's chief minister for the last two months (49 days to be specific) Mr. Arvind Kejriwal finally resigned. He has promised that if he cannot pass the Jan Lokpal bill in the Delhi assembly, he will resign. This is the bill for which a few of them back then started the India Against Corruption (IAC) movement and later formed the party (AAP) and fought the election in Delhi. This was the first promise in their manifesto, the basic foundation on which their party was formed, and the reason they fought elections. Now some people and two major parties of India (BJP and Congress) are calling AK a traitor and a coward who ran away from responsibility. One of them (BJP) called him opportunistic and power-hungry when he accepted the unconditional support offered by the Congress to form the government and now they are blaming him for creating crises in Delhi by resigning from the CM post. It is not uncommon for these parties to criticize no matter what their opponent does, so it's not a surprise that this tamasha (drama) has been going on in India for the last many years and still people enjoy this sitting in their living rooms.

I think AK should be arrested and tried in court for crimes he committed during the last few months. It will at least prevent something like this from happening again in the near future. How did he dare to challenge such a robust establishment? How did he dare to challenge the norms and rules set by the central government? How did he dare to protest in Delhi when he was chief minister of that state? Do chief ministers even behave like this? How did he dare to challenge the power of the central govt., Delhi police and Lt. Governor of Delhi at the same time? How did he dare to name the most powerful businessman of India and a cabinet minister both in one FIR? These are the few serious mistakes he made during the last few months. Wasn't he scared? Wasn't he worried about his CM post? What was he even thinking when he challenged this mighty political establishment that has been running this country for the last 65 years or so? How he dare to think that a common person like him could form a political party and challenge the grand old political parties who all know how to govern India as politics and governance flow in their blood. They all know how to win the elections and govern this great country and this maniac thought he could govern better than them? Anarchist, what else one can call him?

Didn't he know that many people are not yet ready for complete freedom (Swaraj)? People are against power decentralization, they want some messiah or dynast to rule them, not some common person, because all these people coming from the establishment know how to rule, how to govern, what a novice who didn't have any political background know about governance, right? People want some charismatic hero whom they can worship, adore, and believe blindly without questioning anything. What is a common man like him doing in politics? Clearly, he was a complete misfit in our corrupt system and therefore he needed to go, it was just a matter of time. Here, I am not talking about AK as a person but AK as an idea. As a person he is not that important, he may have all the drawbacks or strengths that we all have, but this idea of a noncorrupt novice leading any government needs to be crushed so that there can not be another AK. If common people realize that any one of them can become a leader then it will be dangerous for the current establishment. One AK is so difficult to deal with then imagine if everyone becomes like him. No, this should not happen at any cost, if this happens it will be like a death sentence for the current system, that's why AK's actions should be treated like blasphemy or treason. Actually, I am a little surprised to see that he dared to stand by his promise (to resign if Lokpal is not passed). Very few political leaders in India show the courage to renounce power like this, his government was short-lived but it tried its best as long as it existed. I am sure everyone from our grand political establishment has only one question in their mind, how Arvind dared to resign from CM's post like this? 

Thanks for reading and please share your opinion about this topic.

[Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing]

Saturday, January 11, 2014

Why I decided to support AAP?

Last month results of the assembly elections in five states in India were declared, and most results were as expected except for the result of India's national capital New Delhi, A rookie party AAP came second. Surprisingly, it won 28 seats, only 8 short of getting an absolute majority in a 70-member assembly. Their phenomenal success surprised many, including me. I expected some impact from AAP, but unexpectedly they created a huge impact, so huge that now there is a government by AAP managing the administration of Delhi. During that election I did one thing that I never do during any election, I openly supported AAP. I endorsed this party openly and even campaigned for them via phone calls to Delhi voters. This was the first time I campaigned for any political party directly. I voted many times during various elections (state, national, municipal) in India, I voted for different parties in different elections. I am not a supporter or member of any single political party, my choice was based on the situation and need of that time. During local elections, I voted for the Shivsena candidate even though I didn't agree with many of their policies or their ideology. I voted for them just because their local candidate was really helpful and supportive of our entire neighborhood. Likewise, I chose different parties in different elections (state or national). I was impressed by the honesty and youthfulness of Rajiv when he entered politics, VP Singh's anti-corruption drive attracted me, Manmohan Singh's economic policies after 1991 created a lot of change and hope, and Vajpayee's honesty and sincerity impressed me, but I also didn't like or disagreed with many things related to the governments headed by each of these leaders. I had really high hopes for Manmohan Singh as PM of India, not every time I was right or my expectations were fulfilled but I was never (and still I am not) a fan of any one political leader or party. I support a good candidate or policy, it doesn't matter from which party they come. There are some basic principles on which I will never compromise but apart from them, governance is the key issue that I consider while voting. So, why did I decide to support AAP this time? What made me to change my stand of not supporting any party openly, why I didn't keep my political inclination a private affair this time?

During every election campaign, all parties promise so many things that they never even try to fulfill. They try to field winnable candidates, and they even field candidates with very questionable backgrounds just because they have the power and capacity to fight and win elections. Every major political (state or national) party does these things there are very no exceptions to this. From the beginning, AAP was different than all of them. First, they declared their all funding sources and amounts, and everything was available online for anyone to check. To date, no other political party in India has done this. It seems they have too much to hide, AAP was the first to do it. AAP was also the first party to disqualify their candidate from their party when they found some corruption charges against that candidate. They did this even after the deadline of withdrawing nominations expired. This was again a unique step. With actions like these, they showed their uniqueness and transparency from the beginning. All these things were enough for me to believe in their sincerity. I don't agree with some of their populist policies, and I am even not sure if they will live up to all expectations, but at least they are trying sincerely and that's the main reason I support them. I am also not expecting any overnight change, it will be a very long and difficult battle with many ups and downs. In the past many parties that came out of some movement and claimed to work to deliver social justice surrendered to the current political system and became an integral part of it once they got power. They didn't even try to change the system but became part of the system. Now they all are busy navigating their way to the top using the same old techniques and methods. AAP didn't do this, at least not yet, and this is what made me support them.

This was the first time I felt that any political party in India was not playing politics of caste and religion during the election., This was the first time that some party talked about overall system reforms not just an empty promise of good governance. As Amir Khan said in one of his interviews this was for the first time when some party promised not to offer a good rule but to act as people's representative and execute what people want. This was the first time that any party did a referendum to ask people whether they should form a government with the outside support of the party against which they fought the election. This party seems to care what people like me think, they seem to listen to our demands. They didn't go and settle in VIP culture after getting elected. They look very accessible and approachable. For the first time people seem to have the power to challenge the government, ask questions, demand action and pull it down if they don't like their work. For the first time, any CM has to change his official residence because many people disapprove of his choice. Many see this incident as a weakness and lack of leadership for me it was walking the talk (their promise that people are in charge). For the first time, ministers declined the security cover (however personally I feel this is unnecessary). For the first time, ministers won't travel in cars with red beacons. Some politicians practiced many of these things individually but for the first time, any political party included these things in their rule book and followed it. For me these things are enough to show that currently this party is different than many others out there and as long as they remain different, and don't deviate from their path I will support them. The day they deviate from their path, engage in the same old tactics, or become corrupt I will be the first to criticize and oppose them because my support is not blind and unconditional. I am not a devotee but just a supporter who is with them to build a great and prosperous nation.

I am waiting for the day when all other parties will become totally transparent in their activities and funding, field clean candidates, try to fulfill their election promises, and if the presence of AAP forces them to do this then I think this will be the greatest contribution by AAP to Indian politics. If this happens then uniqueness of AAP will diminish and every other party will become like AAP, and there will be competition to provide honest and noncorrupt governance to people and that will be a true democracy. I am waiting for that day. I hope AAP stays on its path till then if it deviates or changes its direction drastically it will lose the support of me and many people like me, this might happen as nothing is guaranteed but as always I am optimistic.

Thanks for reading and please share your views on this topic.

[Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing]

Links:
1. http://www.aamaadmiparty.org/

Friday, December 13, 2013

AAP should not remain just a political party but should become a phenomena

The recent success of AAP (Aam Aadami Party) in the Delhi elections has created a lot of buzz all over India. Many political parties poked fun when AAP was created almost one year back and even dismissed their presence. They termed it as a temporary phenomenon, a bubble that will eventually disappear without creating any significant impact. But destiny had something else in its mind. The spectacular performance by the AAP in the Delhi elections left everyone shocked and surprised. They won 28 out of 70 seats, no one expected this to happen. They not only fought the election but fought really hard. During the India Against Corruption (IAC) movement, the current political brigade challenged a few common people not to just protest on the street and create a nuisance but to enter the political system and try to clean it if they are not happy with the current system. They never imagined that some people would really take this challenge seriously and take a plunge into the muddy water of politics. They tried everything from sting operations to government investigation about their funding, but nothing worked against AAP. So far they came out of all troubles successfully and managed to maintain their clean image.

I am not excited about AAP only as a new political entity, there are so many political parties in India, local as well as national, they all were launched with a lot of good intentions and some of them became very successful. However, they all became part of the same system and played the game with the same set of rules which included the use of money power, corruption, and many other illegal ways about which most people are aware. Skepticism about AAP was quite understandable because people saw many new parties emerging and becoming part of the same system many times before. Leaders like Laloo Yadav, Mulayam Singh, and Mayavati, came from very humble backgrounds and entered politics with a lot of good intentions but today they are big players in the same system, playing by the same rules. They couldn't change the system but the system changed them completely. But so far AAP seems to be different. They have a totally different approach and transparency is the most important aspect of their approach which impressed me a lot. Whatever they do including the collection of money to run the party is in the public domain. No other political party has done this before. Everyone thought that no one could survive in Indian politics with honesty and complete transparency but so far AAP has done it. This is what scared other parties, they are scared to disclose their sources of funding, and they are worried about losing the election if they don't field popular or winnable candidates. They all used to field such candidates and never used to care even if some of these candidates have criminal backgrounds, but now they may not be able to do it anymore. At least they were forced to field honest candidates with clean images during the Delhi elections just because of the presence of AAP. This is what makes me excited about AAP. Not only they are playing the game honestly but they are also forcing their opponents to follow the same path. This is what I want to happen, reformation of all parties and the entire system. One candidate or leader with good intentions is not a big deal. They are there in every party but when every party and candidate is forced to stay clean and work honestly then only desired reform will happen. First, there has to be some external pressure (which AAP has created) and then slowly it may become a norm and then we may not even need to mention specifically AAP's name because all parties will be like them. This sounds like a crazy dream today but I am optimistic.

AAP has still a long way to go. They just started and hit a home run in their first attempt, but that doesn't mean they will remain like this or will have the same success in every election they contest, but it seems they are not worried about that and I like this attitude. They seem to be more interested in overall political reform rather than short-term gains. That's why I think it's not just another political party but a phenomenon that made common people believe that they also can enter politics and win, they also can dream of challenging this corrupt system if they want and this is what excites me and makes me optimistic. Many say that nothing can be done with our current political and bureaucratic machinery, it's damaged beyond any repair, but AAP's success and approach are a ray of hope. They showed us not everything is lost and it's we who can repair it and change it, it's our responsibility to fight for the change we want. So now the ball is in our court, we need to make sure that AAP just doesn't remain another political party but becomes a phenomenon, an experiment that can be repeated everywhere and at every level. If not, then we will be stuck with the current rotten system for many more years to come and I don't think any of us want this to happen. I am happy for AAP's success, more than that I am happy for myself, I am happy for the common people of India who desperately needed some ray of hope and now they have it.

Thanks for reading and please share your views on this topic.

[Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing]

Saturday, November 9, 2013

Is AAP anti-national?

Recently Bharatiya Janata Party leader Dr. Subramanian Swamy (Dr. SS) called the Aam Aadami Party (AAP) an anti-national party. Dr. SS is very well known for making controversial statements as well as sensational accusations, he has been doing this for a long time, but most of the time media used to ignore his statements. Nowadays he is again a popular figure in Indian politics because of the role played by him in the 2G spectrum scam case which resulted in the arrest of Mr. A. Raja (minister of communications and IT, 2007-2009) and a few others. The case created a lot of controversies and media hype, and because of all this nowadays his statements are getting a lot of media coverage and attention. This man always amazes me with his statements and articles. He is such a talented and intelligent person, with a good intention and some good ideas to make India a better country, but because of his sectarian views and personal hatred for some people (like Gandhis), he sometimes makes such horrendous statements that one is forced to wonder about his mental state. I think his recent statement related to AAP came because of somewhat different views of some AAP leaders on the Kashmir issue and the recent meeting of Mr. Arawind Kejriwal (AK) with controversial cleric Tauqueer Raza Khan, who allegedly issued a fatwa against Bangladeshi writer Taslima Nasreen.

Dr. SS didn't like that one of the members of AAP Mr. Prashant Bhushan said that a plebiscite could be one of the solutions which can help to reduce the alienation of people of Kashmir. AAP had distanced itself from Mr. Bhushan's views calling it his personal opinion and not the party's stand. However, in India, it's very rare to see a politician who can have totally opposite or different views on any sensitive topic than their party's view. Actually, I like this aspect of AAP where a person is not forced to accept the party's stand if they do not agree with it. People should not be penalized for expressing what they believe, this should be allowed and welcomed in a true democracy. People with different opinions can also team up and work together for the betterment of society and the country. I don't think there is anything wrong with it. 

AAP has tried to maintain complete transparency in their financial dealings as well as candidate selection for election. No other party including Dr. SS's own party operates in such a transparent way. Many antisocial elements, people who are facing serious criminal charges get tickets to contest elections from these national parties in the name of political compulsion. They offer excuses like if we don't give the ticket someone else will give it to them, at least AAP is not playing this dirty game and should be applauded for that. As far as Mr. AK's meeting with Tauqueer Raza Khan is concerned, if AK did it only to gather Muslim votes then he and AAP will pay the price for it, but if he did this just to reach every section of society then there is nothing wrong in it. After all, Tauqueer Raza Khan is an Indian citizen, he and whatever community he represents is part of our country, and treating any person as untouchable is not a solution. This is the same BJP who is trying hard to make their prime ministerial candidate Mr. Narendra Modi acceptable to the whole of India (especially to Muslims). They claim he should not be branded as a communal just because of one riot that happened during his tenure in Gujarat, but Dr. SS is not willing to apply the same criteria when it comes to leaders of other communities, how hypocritical? And if Dr. SS is doing all this just to create some controversy and media attention then this is really pathetic and not expected from him. Maybe recent media exposure and popularity have created some sort of pressure or desire in him to remain in the constant limelight. If this is the case, then it's a sad end of an intellectual who had much more potential and capability than just to make some controversial and sensational statements.

I hope people like Dr. SS concentrate on the future of their own party and work towards building a strong India. If people like him are going to judge parties based on the personal opinions of some of their members then I hope they apply the same criteria to their own party also and they accept if someone calls them a party of criminals or rapists or porn watchers. If not, then they should just stop using such double standards, and if they want they can offer some constructive criticism. AAP with all its problems and drawbacks is at least trying to do something different, something which never happened in Indian politics before. I can understand the discomfort of all national parties, I see that they don't appreciate this and like the rise and popularity of AAP. Such wild accusations are not expected at least from a person like Dr. SS. Such accusations may ultimately help AAP and expose the double standards of other political parties. We all know that even AAP is not perfect but at least please don't stoop to such a low level to malign them, it looks pathetic.

Thanks for reading and please share your views on this topic.

[Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing]

controversial cleric Tauqeer Raza Khan, who had issued a fatwa against Bangladeshi writer Taslima Nasreen.

Read more at: http://ibnlive.in.com/news/bjp-accuses-aap-of-attracting-antinational-elements-to-the-party/432473-80-258.html?utm_source=ref_article
controversial cleric Tauqeer Raza Khan, who had issued a fatwa against Bangladeshi writer Taslima Nasreen.

Read more at: http://ibnlive.in.com/news/bjp-accuses-aap-of-attracting-antinational-elements-to-the-party/432473-80-258.html?utm_source=ref_article
controversial cleric Tauqeer Raza Khan, who had issued a fatwa against Bangladeshi writer Taslima Nasreen.

Read more at: http://ibnlive.in.com/news/bjp-accuses-aap-of-attracting-antinational-elements-to-the-party/432473-80-258.html?utm_source=ref_article
controversial cleric Tauqeer Raza Khan, who had issued a fatwa against Bangladeshi writer Taslima Nasreen.

Read more at: http://ibnlive.in.com/news/bjp-accuses-aap-of-attracting-antinational-elements-to-the-party/432473-80-258.html?utm_source=ref_article
Links:

Saturday, September 29, 2012

Anna or Kejriwal, who is right?

Recently Anna Hazare announced that he is not going to be a part of the new political party or movement that Arvind Kejriwal is planning to start soon. It was surprising, if not shocking to know this. Forming a political party and taking this anti-corruption movement to the next level was the next logical step in the direction of bringing reforms to our corrupt political and bureaucratic system. The question that comes to my mind is why Anna chose to stay away from a political option? Is it because he feels that involvement in politics will corrupt his movement? Does he think that politics is a dirty game and wants to play safe? What is it, that made him take this decision, and what effect this decision can have on the current political and social scenario? Who is right, Anna or Arvind?

Anti-corruption movement started with a bang when Anna Hazare sat on his fist fast for the Lokpal issue and it charged the whole nation. The problem was there, everyone knew it, and people responded spontaneously which even took the government by surprise. For people of my generation, this movement is a chance to be a part of Indian history, our generation never witnessed any part of the freedom struggle, we were just kids or infants during the emergency, but we can be a very important part of this important movement and that's why it means a lot for our generation.

At the beginning of the movement people's response to it created a lot of hope and many things happened after that. A committee was set up for the Janlokpal bill draft formation and discussion, this didn't work out very well as there were huge differences between the government's version of the Lokpal bill and Team Anna's version. The government prepared its own Lokpal bill and introduced it in parliament, there was a heated debate on the contents of that bill and the effectiveness of this newly proposed system. In general, this issue was there in the media for 3-4 months, and then slowly attention shifted to some recent scams and fuel price hike-related issues. When Anna sat for his second fast for the same issue, it created much less turmoil and public participation was also less compared to the last time. The government also realized that these things were not going to make any dent in its vote bank or affect its stability so they conveniently ignored the movement. This forced the movement and its leaders to think about alternative ways to fight the anti-corruption battle. I think at this point they realized that just fasting or protests are not going to bring change. It might trouble the ruling party or government for some time and force them to discuss these issues but policies or laws can not be formed or changed by using these ways. Maybe this led them to think of the idea of forming a political party that can give voters an alternative to select honest and sincere candidates who are willing to work for people's welfare rather than working to fulfill some personal ambitions. This sounds more logical but very difficult path to follow. Creating a political party and managing it is not a simple thing in the Indian political system, but without doing this it's foolish to expect that current political parties and politicians will suddenly change their ways and become sincere and honest just because of some protests and fasts. Corruption is not a recent problem in Indian politics or bureaucracy, it's so old that it has become a norm now. I don't think ruling parties will care even if few people die while fasting, it might create some temporary uproar among the public but current establishments know very well how to handle these types of things. These things (protests and fasts) work very well for local issues where urgent attention is required but for national issues like corruption different type of movement is required which can run for a longer time to be effective, 10 day protests or fasts are not going to force the change.

As I mentioned giving people a better political alternative sounds very logical but very difficult option to execute for the anti-corruption movement to move forward. I think initially everyone thought this as a very viable alternative and I remember that Anna Hazare himself announced this option at the end of his second fast in Delhi, but something went wrong in the coming days. Arvind Kejriwal and his followers moved forward to form a political group and I think others decided to wait and watch. This resulted in a clear divide in team Anna. One group became totally inactive and waited for Anna's announcement and another group started their work toward the formation of a political outfit. Finally, Anna announced that he wouldn't be a part of any political party, which is totally fine, it's his choice and it should be respected but he also forbade India against corruption or Arvind's group to use his name and image for their movement which is totally surprising. This created a lot of confusion. If it remains like this I am sure this will nullify any effect this movement might have on the next general elections, I don't know which candidates or party Anna and his group are planning to support? Even JP (Jay Prakash Narayan) stood with the Janata Party to bring the change in 1977, he didn't fight the election or accept any post but he clearly associated his name and image with a particular party to bring that change.

Without giving viable political alternatives what Anna expects voters to do? Right now it is very confusing and not a very good scenario for the anti-corruption movement. Either they should associate themselves with some political party that can endorse their ideas and views or form their own party and fight the elections. If they are not willing to do any of these things and just want to play a safe game then there is no point in doing all this because, for any policy change, they have to depend on other political parties which will act only as per their own requirements and benefits. It is difficult to say who is right here, Anna or Kejriwal, but it is also true that both of them should come together to make this battle successful. I hope that this issue between these two groups will be resolved soon and they come up with some common plan that can reignite this movement and initiate the change in the system which is badly required. I know that this is not going to be an easy battle, it will be very long and one can not expect positive results in one or two elections but it should start at least then only we can expect some positive outcome.

Thanks for reading and please share your views on this topic. 

(Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing)