Showing posts with label Mahatma Gandhi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mahatma Gandhi. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 23, 2014

The power of symbolic acts

Champaran or Kheda satyagraha were not very big events in history when they happened in the 1920s. Dandi march or salt march was also not that big deal when it actually happened in 1930 After all, how important was the salt law to the British Raj? Their empire didn't depend on that tax money for survival that's why they didn't bother to stop a political leader from breaking it. With all the power and force in their hands why the administration chose to be a mute spectator even after knowing what Gandhi was capable of doing? When Mahatma Gandhi marched for around 240 miles to break that law what did he achieve by breaking such trivial law? But today this event is considered an important event of the Indian independence movement. This salt march in a way was responsible for initiating the civil disobedience movement on a national level. Through this long and unusual salt march and by breaking a simple law like salt law, Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi showed to the common people of India that the British empire could be challenged by using nonviolent protest. He proved to them with an example that such a mighty empire with all power in its hands could be challenged by nonviolent, unarmed common people. This was the power of that symbolic act. Symbolism plays a very important role in every society. It inspires people, gives them hope, and encourages them to dream the impossible. But why I am suddenly talking about this subject today? This is because of some incidents that happened in India and around the world during the last few months which reminded me of a few of these incidents from Indian history that had a huge impact on the thinking and behavior of common people. People may or may not agree with my views but I see many parallels between some incidents that happened recently and with few pivotal incidents from the Indian freedom movement.

When people from all over India and across the party line stood behind a group of people who started the India Against Corruption (IAC) movement, it resulted in a unique movement. It was one of the scenarios which India never witnessed in a long time. There was no caste, no religion, and no common hatred for any single person or party that united all these people. It was their anger against rampant corruption and the failure of the system to deliver which united them. This movement resulted in the formation of a new and very nonorthodox political party called Aam Aadmi Party (AAP). It won 28 seats in the Delhi assembly elections and even formed a government in the presence of two big and powerful national parties. Then we witnessed some unseen incidents like ministers of the AAP government traveling by public transport for a swearing ceremony, Delhi's chief minister (CM) sleeping on the roadside to protest against the central government, people doing their own sting operations against corrupt officials, etc. These scenes were never witnessed by people before. Delhi CM even resigned after he realized that he could not fulfill the main promise made by their party in their election manifesto. Many people were shocked by these things, and many were angry because they thought CM should never do such things. There is no doubt that these incidents created varied responses and a lot of controversy.

Many of these acts were very symbolic, this was the first time a CM was protesting against the nonaccountability of the police force in his own state. This was the first time in many years any political leader visited his attacker to know the reasons why that person attacked him. But these actions can be considered political stunts or drama by some people, and maybe they are right, only time will give answers to these doubts and concerns. Mahatma Gandhi himself was criticized and ridiculed not only by Britishers but people from his own country for many of his actions, even for his appearance (especially his dress). Some called him a naive politician who didn't know the ground reality in India, a dreamer who was trying to fool people by showing some impossible dream of achieving independence through a nonviolent movement. They called his dressing like the poor of India a political stunt. He also failed in many of his initial endeavors, many times movement took totally unexpected turns and he had to retreat (like the Chauri Chaura incident in 1922). But finally, his struggle helped to achieve India's independence. Along similar lines this movement against rampant corruption in India may take many twists and turns, there may be some failures and setbacks but I hope that finally it achieves its goal.

Symbolism is of great significance in every society. Symbolic acts have the power to inspire millions. These acts can mobilize the masses, and inspire many to participate in the struggle. One simple step like wearing khadi inspired millions to spin charkha during the independence struggle. But the truth is it's relatively easy to start a movement but very difficult to sustain the intensity of movement. It is very difficult to maintain the same level of commitment and transparency. It will be interesting to see in which direction this anti-corruption movement goes, whether it will progress slowly and steadily towards its goal, lose its way and flounder on its own, or these big and powerful parties successfully crush it before it becomes too big and create problems for them. When you don't have money and muscle power to support your cause such symbolic acts can help you to deliver your message. The power of symbolic acts is amazing and currently, we are seeing its effect in India.

Thanks for reading and please share your views on this topic.

[Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing]

Friday, October 4, 2013

Are people like Gandhi and Shastri still relevant today?

Every year 2nd October is celebrated as Mahatma Gandhi and Lal Bahadur Shastri Jayanti (birth anniversary). People remember them, and many Gandhi detractors consider this occasion as a golden opportunity to criticize him for whatever reason they can think of, starting from Muslim appeasement, Hindu hater, India's partition, his nonviolence theory, or anything else. Shastri almost goes unnoticed as people are either busy praising or bashing Gandhi so they don't have time for Shastri as there is nothing much to criticize about him and as he was a staunch Gandhian himself so there is nothing much to praise about him for Gandhi haters except for his simplicity and honesty, so he is not a very attractive target for many. Mahatma Gandhi, Pundit Nehru, Sardar Patel, Bhagat Singh, Shastri, Subhash Bose, Tilak, and Gokhale along with many others (the list is too long) are iconic figures from the freedom movement of India. All these people along with many others contributed tremendously towards India's freedom struggle, but no one receives praise and criticism as much as Gandhi. His name somehow generates extreme reactions, either people think of him as a god-like figure or they criticize him as if he is a monster. His critics call him names like a selfish manipulator, ruthless politician, Muslim sympathizer, Hindu hater, sex pervert, and whatnot. They blame him for India's partition, for the delay in achieving freedom, and for anything that they can think of. His critics try to put as much blame on him for everything wrong that happened during his politically active days in India (~1920-1948). Some of them even go to the extent of justifying his assassination and many of them are big fans of his murderer Nathuram Godse. Godse's court speech is very popular among them, this speech which is available on the internet is no different than any fanatic terrorist's speech. These people revere Godse's speech so much but surprisingly despise similar speeches by other terrorists who carry similar justifications. Some groups claim to follow Gandhi but actually, they use his image and name purely for selfish reasons, just as some marketing tool, they absolutely don't show any commitment towards his causes and principles. This behavior always raises a question in my mind, are people like Gandhi and Shastri still relevant in today's world? Are they mere marketing tools, just statues and posters that people visit once or twice a year and then forget until next year?

It's quite normal to have differences of opinion in politics and Gandhi, Nehru, Tilak, or any other leader of their stature were all politicians, they all believed in certain ideologies and tried to propagate them as much as possible. These leaders tried to direct the freedom movement based on the ideologies they believed in. Gandhi was the most popular leader of all. One can criticize their approach or question their methods, there is nothing wrong with it. Whatever these people did, right or wrong it can be debated, but they all meant good, intention was to take India forward, do something for its people, not to hurt anyone or neglect any community purposely. To hate any political leader just because of ideological differences to the extent to justify their assassination is insane. How can one justify the murder of an opponent just for ideological differences? No wonder that the same people then go on to justify other violent acts like communal riots also.

I was always fascinated by the lives of all these leaders. I read about them and get a lot of inspiration from their work but I don't associate myself with any particular camp or ideology. For me, Gandhi was a great human being with very honest intentions and a great leader who managed to involve common people in the freedom movement. At the same time, Gandhi was also a politician, very religious and fanatic about some of his personal beliefs, the same thing is true about many other great leaders. They all have certain great qualities and some not-so-great qualities, but in general, their greatness overshadows all other things that's why they are respected. I take whatever I find good from their teachings and leave the rest or question it, argue it, or criticize it, but I don't hate any person just because I don't agree with a few of their ideas and principles.

People like Gandhi or Nehru never ran away from criticism or troubles, they always faced it and tried to solve the problems or conflicts in politics via dialogues not by force or violence, at least this is one thing we all can learn from them. Their personal honesty and integrity were their strength, and they never forced their personal beliefs on anyone, they kept their personal faith separate from their politics. How many leaders do we have today who even know the meaning of honesty and integrity? For today's generation, many ideas and principles of these people look outdated and difficult to practice. For example, simplicity is no more a virtue, and nonviolence is mostly perceived as a weakness. Consumerism is a need of today's economy and there is a lot of pressure and encouragement to consume, and enjoy life without any social responsibilities. This all makes people like Gandhi and  Shastri more relevant today. We need to follow at least some of their ideas to bring balance to our lives. We either like to go too much right (extreme capitalism) or too much left (communism), and no one likes to be in the center because then they feel like an orphan. People feel isolated if they don't belong to any group, they feel obliged to choose a camp. We admire these leaders but hesitate to pave our own way and prefer to choose some popular belief and try to become a part of an established group. We don't need to worship these people, that's a useless thing to do but we should discuss them, debate their ideas, offer constructive criticism, refine relevant ideas, and implement them. I hope people find their ideas more useful than their photos or statues.

Thanks for reading and please share your views on this topic. 

[Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing]

Tuesday, October 2, 2012

Mahatma Gandhi - from my eyes


I wrote a similar post on my Facebook page a couple of years ago and I thought it was worth sharing on my blog on the occasion of Gandhi Jayanti (2nd October). Mahatma Gandhi is one of the most popular at the same time one of the most widely criticized personalities in India. Some parties and people use his name and image for their political gain and at the same time, some criticize him for similar purposes. If one searches on the internet then one can find many articles, blogs, social media posts, groups, and many other things about Gandhi. People question his principles, question their relevance in today's world, various forums discuss how India benefited from his ideologies or how he ruined India's prospectus of becoming super power by introducing this 'nonviolence' thing (Ahinsa, अहिंसा). There is an ample amount of food for thought related to his personality and ideologies. Both pro and anti-Gandhi groups are very good in their arguments and try their best to prove their points by citing many examples from history to show how he failed or excelled in certain situations. To my surprise, some of his critics go to the extent of justifying his assassination by Nathuram Godse and even claim that India benefited from this cowardly act of Nathuram.

No doubt that Mahatma Gandhi was one of the most influential and powerful personalities of the 20th century. He had a profound influence on the Indian independence movement. He believed in a certain ideology and he practiced that till the end of his life. His ideology for him was above everything, including his own life. I am really impressed by his solidarity toward his convictions and beliefs.

Gandhi is criticized for many things. His detractors often criticize him for his pro-Muslim stand, blame him for not trying enough to stop Bhagat Singh’s execution, blame him for the partition of India, and also think he was responsible for destroying the armed struggle movement for independence. I really feel surprised how one can blame a single person without any position of power for so many things. If one looks at Gandhi’s lifestyle he was a staunch follower of Hinduism (with all his prayers and vegetarian diet etc.) but he is considered as pro-Muslim? I just don’t understand this accusation against him, maybe this is related to his stance to give Pakistan 55 crores which India promised. 

I can’t understand how people even think that he could have managed to stop the execution of Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev, and Rajguru. He was not part of the British judiciary system; he never practiced law once he returned to India from South Africa, then how?? By going on a hunger strike? By begging to British government for their pardon? What about many others who faced a similar fate, was Gandhi responsible for their deaths also? Both of them (Gandhi and Bhagat Singh) believed in certain ideologies and they followed them till the end of their life. I don’t think they needed or even expected each other's support because their paths were totally different. I don’t remember any of the armed struggle revolutionaries ever supporting Gandhi’s ideas and his views but they don’t get accused for not supporting Gandhi but Gandhi gets accused all the time for not doing anything for them. I don't know why? I don’t think people like Bhagat Singh even needed Gandhi’s support for their mission. All of them were great in their own manure and did great work and sacrifices for our nation, so what’s the point of dragging Gandhi into everything. It's very simple to understand that Gandhi never believed in their line of thinking and they didn’t believe in Gandhi’s, their ways were separate from the beginning, so one should not expect them to support or endorse each other even though their ultimate target was the same.

People often forget one very important thing, Gandhiji was a also politician and member of a political party (Indian National Congress, INC). His biggest contribution to the freedom struggle was that he took the freedom movement to the masses. He went where no political leader of the freedom movement had gone before. He went to rural India, stayed with common people, understood their problems, and solved them by getting those people involved. He showed them that they have power and can fight any injustice, that’s why he was so popular and his movement could attract people from all classes. The appeal of leaders like Lokamanya Tilak, Gokhale, Savarkar, Bose, Ambedkar, Nehru, Patel, and Maulana Azad was limited to a particular class of society like intellectuals and the educated young generation. I think this is one of the reasons none of them could control INC like Gandhi did even though they were active members of that party before him and spent their entire life in India (Gandhi arrived on the Indian political scene only in the 1920s, when he was already above 40).

Gandhi believed in non-violence totally. He made it his mission and preached it. Apart from non-violence, he believed in many other things like celibacy, self-reliance, etc. It is also true that many times he was very adamant and forceful about his views. There are some examples where he advised newly married couples to follow celibacy in their married life (JP Narayan is an example of this). After all, he was human like all of us, full of many good and some not-so-good qualities, and people often forget this fact when they praise him or criticize him. There are many instances like this about his private and political life but we look at them from by considering him as human not 'Mahatma' we can understand them in a much better way. 

He tried his best to avoid India’s partition but failed and along with him all other political leaders and parties also failed to avoid it so all of them are guilty of that unfortunate incident. It's unfair to blame only him for this incident. He was against violence, so whether it was Hindus killing Muslims or the other way he was against it. It's wrong to blame him for the killings of Hindus during the partition. Rather he was the only person who tried his best to convince them to stop that madness. He lived his life based on his principles and died for them. Nathuram Godse killed Gandhiji because of ideological differences and I fail to understand how can people support this act in their wildest of dreams. I wonder how can one justify killing somebody just because they don’t agree with his/her ideology? Can any ideological differences be the reason for killing a person? Is violence the way to settle these types of issues? Godse took the easiest path available to him because he could not fight Gandhi ideologically. If Godse believed he was right then he should have convinced people of his ideas. People of India who supported Gandhi were not fools. If Godse was right they definitely would have listened to him as they did to Gandhi. So why did he murder Gandhi? Is this what we want our youths to follow? if you can't defeat somebody ideologically then murder them?

It's very easy to blame Gandhi but it takes some time and patience to understand him. People who blame him never give him any credit that he deserves. As a politician some of his actions were definitely questionable but that’s true with all politicians be it Nehru, Patel, Bose, Indira, or anyone else, that's a part and parcel of a politician's life. He made certain mistakes in his life like all of us do but unlike most of us, he showed courage to accept many of them. He totally believed in non-violence and practiced it himself and at that time many people in India agreed with his philosophy and followed him, we can not blame him for that. Just try to lead a peaceful protest of a few people and see how difficult it is to control the crowd and then imagine how easy it was for this man to guide the entire nation towards a non-violent freedom struggle.

Gandhi was a great leader but that doesn’t take away any credit from other freedom fighters. They all did their part and were also responsible for achieving India's freedom. I am not pro or anti-Gandhi, I don't understand why always we have to take sides. Can’t we take all the good qualities of all great people and try to make this planet a better place? These people fought with the British for our independence, instead of working towards building a strong nation do we want to keep on fighting among ourselves for them? Think about it.

Thanks for reading and your comments are always welcome. 

(Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing)

Power of non-violence

2nd October is Gandhi Jayanti (birth date of Mahatma Gandhi), on that day many people all over the world pay tribute to this great leader from India who played a key role in India's Independence struggle. The unique feature of his movement was the role that non-violence (अहिंसा) played in it and he is remembered as the ultimate icon who demonstrated the power of non-violence to fight against injustice or violence. Violence or armed struggle played a major role in most of the freedom struggles or revolutions all over the world, till now we fought two world wars where millions of people died which is why Gandhiji's movement is considered unique and its success is still a point of discussion and debate. Many people around the world were inspired by the success of his movement and implemented it in their own movements some of the more recent examples are Dr. Nelson Mandela from South Africa and Suu Kyi from Myanmar.

This does not mean that non-violence is a very popular method for protest or fight against injustice violence is very much there but I think more people are using this method over violent options. Unfortunately, it's not happening on the scale on which it should happen. I hope it happens in the near future but it doesn't look like it will, still, there is a huge majority in the world that believes a violent path is the only way to achieve their targets, it's unfortunate and sad but it's true. Gandhi's name is somehow associated with non-violence and anyone advocating non-violence philosophy is branded as a believer in Gandhian philosophy. Gandhi had many beliefs one of them was the power of non-violence as an effective tool to fight against injustice. His book 'My Experiments With Truth' gives a general idea about the principles he believed in and one can realize that non-violence was just one of them for which he became world famous. I am quite impressed by his personality, I love his conviction and beliefs in his own ideas and principles but I am not his blind follower. I know that Gandhi was a politician and a lawyer also and above all he was also a human like us, full of great qualities and some not so great. He played a major role in achieving India's freedom from the British by using non-violent protest as an effective tool. He was instrumental in motivating masses of India who were not part of the freedom struggle before he entered Indian politics. One has to give him credit for taking this freedom struggle movement to the masses and making them believe that they could also fight with the powerful British empire.

Non-violence doesn't mean total surrender and it's definitely not a sign of weakness. A person who tolerates violence in any form because he/she can not fight or is scared to fight is definitely not following non-violence. Such a person is forced to follow it because of a lack of options or courage, but when a person chooses a non-violent path over other options available then only it can be said that he/she is following it truly. Non-violence works only when it is followed by choice, not because of lack of options. Many people make fun of non-violence philosophy and say it won't work everywhere, they cite many examples to prove their point. Indeed, it may not work everywhere but there is nothing that is guaranteed to work everywhere. Everyone is aware of the power of violence, no one can deny it but the problem is that it also doesn't work everywhere and I think there are ample examples around us to demonstrate this fact. The problem with violence is, once it starts it becomes uncontrollable, and even if it works it leaves a lot of negative emotions and damage behind. It leaves a permanent scar on the minds of the people involved. There are no winners or losers in violence but that's the not case with non-violence, it may not work always but it won't lead to mass destruction or riots.

It's not that we need to wait for Gandhi Jayanti every year to pay tribute to Gandhiji and remember the power of non-violence. I think people should make this philosophy an integral part of their lives, let's try to choose non-violence over violence wherever it is possible. I am not talking only about physical violence here but violence in any form, for example, even thinking bad about someone or verbal abuse, racial or gender discrimination, are some sort of acts of violence. I know it's not that easy for many of us. We are one of the animal species on this planet and will always have that animal instinct in us. So, I know that it will be difficult to totally irradiate violence from our lives. But as humans, we know that we are very different than other animals of this universe, we have created such a beautiful world around us and only our violent acts can destroy it from our side, so let's try to control it as much as possible. Remember, an eye for an eye will make the whole world blind.

Thanks for reading and please share your views on this topic. 

(Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing)