Showing posts with label Belief. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Belief. Show all posts

Monday, June 15, 2015

Science is NOT my religion

I have written quite a few posts about science and religion. I know some people who call science their religion, and whereas I do understand their intention behind saying this, I don't subscribe to that idea, for me it is very clear that science is NOT my religion. I say so because of one basic fundamental difference, religion demands total surrender and requires complete faith (blind faith), it allows questions but only to a certain limit and there are certain areas in almost all religions that are unquestionable and their authority is considered as supreme, but science has none of these things. Science is not my faith, I don't believe anything that comes from that field blindly, I need data to accept or reject anything no matter who is the scientist behind that theory or experiment. This basic difference is the key to understanding why both of these disciplines are poles apart from each other.

So, when someone says that science is their religion, they might mean that they believe in science in the same way people believe in religion. But then there is one basic problem in this argument, science does not demand any belief or faith, rather it teaches us to be skeptical about everything. One of the basic requisites for being a good scientist is the ability to question things around us and challenge well-established facts to test if they are still right or if we need to update them. There is nothing in science that demands any belief or surrender, experiments and data collected from those experiments supersede any rules or theories. Anything can be proven right or wrong by experimental evidence. Scientists don't believe in the validity of one of the most famous scientific equations, E=MC2, just because a great scientist like Albert Einstein proposed it, they accepted it because it was proven to be true by experimental data. The same is true for theories proposed by Newton, Galileo, or any other scientist of any era. Certain statements or theories might get some recognition in the beginning just because some famous or successful scientist proposed it but eventually, it has to pass the test of experimental validity. Someone needs to produce the data to prove or disprove them and this can be done by anyone without being threatened or heckled by supporters of that theory. Any such effort where a certain theory is proven right or wrong by experimental evidence is welcomed by the entire scientific community, even students of the scientist whose theory is proven wrong welcome any such effort as it improves their knowledge. This is the basic reason why there is no enmity between different branches of science. There is competition between various branches but at the same time, there is a vast amount of inter-disciplinary collaborations.

Challenging well-established theories, questioning hypotheses, and demanding data to prove any claim are some of the basic things that people learn in science but it is exactly the opposite in religion where one is taught to accept the supremacy of some entity and then asked to follow certain book (or set of books). Questioning is highly restricted and often sensitivities of followers of that religion get hurt if anyone questions their beliefs beyond a certain point. At the same time, there is tremendous tension between various religions. Human history is full of gory violent incidents because of communal conflicts between two or more religions. I do understand the need to have religion for many people, as many of us need some emotional support and religion acts as a pillar of strength for many. Maybe science partly does that job for me as it answers many questions that I get from time to time. Actually, science is a very useful tool for me to navigate through my life but nothing more than that, it can never become a religion for me just because I don't agree with the way religion is practiced in today's world. Even today religion fails to come any close to science as far as openness and tolerance are concerned. Because of this tolerance which I learned during my training as a scientist, I don't mind people questioning whatever I say or write, they have the freedom and right to do that. My sensitivities and beliefs are my problem, and people don't have to worry about them while questioning me or criticizing me. That is why I can categorically say that science is not my religion.

Thanks for reading and please share your views on this topic.

[Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing]

Friday, March 23, 2012

Does Religion Divide or Unite People?

This is a very complex and challenging topic and includes many layers. What makes me ask this question? Why was religion created? What is its situation today? Is there any need for religion in today’s world? These are very relevant and important questions.

Many centuries ago, we didn't have a proper understanding of things like nature, life, and its complexities, and many other things. People at that time needed a system that could help them solve these mysteries, and religion was born to explain these things. It tried to do the same thing that science does for us today, that is, to offer some explanation about the questions and concerns of society. Religion did it without much experimentation or empirical evidence on which today's science is based. Another important question is if God/truth is one, then why do we have so many religions in the world? Before the beginning of the modern era, modes of communication were not well developed, and knowledge or information generated was difficult to communicate and transfer, so people living in different regions developed their own way of understanding nature and its functioning. This gave birth to so many religions that we see around us today. They are very different in their approach, but all try to explain the world through some superpower that they think created and controls this universe. Religion is nothing but a belief system that was created to help people understand the mysteries of the universe. It helped to satisfy people's curiosity about uncertainty and unpredictability in life. People who believe in a certain set of ideas about the creation of the universe and its creator associate themselves with a certain type of religion.

Now let’s try to understand why every religion claims that its way or method is correct/better than others and is their claim right? Suppose we assume that number 4 is the ultimate truth (or God). Someone who discovers 2+2=4 will think he/she found the secret of the ultimate truth, and that’s the way to go; in a way, he/she is right. However, if he/she think (as most religious groups who believe in their scriptures blindly think) that’s the only way to reach 4, then they are definitely wrong, 1+3=4, 5-1=4, 10-6=4, and like that, there are so many ways to reach that ultimate target, and each of them is unique and correct in its own way. By this logic, I think that every person is entitled to have his/her own religion. What most of us do is stick with one method that we like or feel is correct and say all other methods are wrong. All religions agree that god is one, but then again fight over ways to reach or please that god. This simple math example shows that there are many ways to reach the same destination.

When I came across different faiths and tried to understand them, I didn’t find anything fundamentally different in any of them; rather, it amazed me that there are so many ways to teach basically the same philosophy. The presence of many religions should make humans happy. If someone doesn’t like one particular religion, just choose another, pretty simple. Either everyone is right, or all are wrong. When we understand this, then there won’t be any problem in understanding each other's faiths and beliefs. The world will be a beautiful place with no hatred no fight based on religion, and there will be at least one less reason to kill each other. Hinduism is often criticized for its idol worship and having many Gods-demigods, or seeing god in everything (trees, fire, air, stones, etc.). It's written in the Vedas that the creator of the universe is a formless, imageless, and genderless entity. However, if you assume there is some creator or god, then what’s wrong in having some image of that god using our imagination and giving it some name? Already, we created religion, so what’s wrong with creating God, and then why not have many forms of it? It’s like having a vending machine from which one can choose whichever God he/she likes. If they are different forms of the same thing, then what’s the problem? If you like, nothing wrong in worshiping God as a formless entity, and also nothing wrong in worshiping it in some form; everyone is entitled to have their own God, it's a personal thing. If we agree that all religions lead to the same ultimate truth, then why question others' methods? In science, there are different branches, and all try to look for scientific facts. However, a chemist doesn't ridicule a physicist or try to convert them to a chemist. This is because they both know that even though their ways are different, they are leading to the same destination. If everyone is heading to the same destination but just taking a different path, then what's the problem? 

Why don’t humans wonder if religion was created to unite us and make us more civilized and tolerant towards each other? Why are we doing exactly the opposite?  Today, religion divides more than unites people, and we have to blame ourselves for this situation. This is why I asked in the beginning, do we even need religion anymore? We converted religion into exclusive societies, where people believing certain sets of principles are welcomed but not others. Let’s stop this division and hatred based on religion and live like civilized humans are supposed to live. Humanity is the only religion everybody is born with; let's not try to divide more.

Thanks for reading and please share your views and questions on this topic.

Related links for further reading:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religious_persecution

(Copyright: Vinay Thakur. Please contact the author for re-posting or publishing)